Previous Visitor Comments
|The issue I’ve always had with the midi-chlorians is that they don’t rlealy read as anything other than a plot point. The vagueness of their relationship with the Jedi and The Force makes them irrelevant to the larger plot of the films and they don’t serve to add anything concretely new to the mythology of the universe. It feels like George Lucas felt obliged to point out how The Force actually works and tossed off an answer rather than actually revealing something that’s fundamentally important to the viewer’s comprehension of the Star Wars universe.|
|This is thoughtful and great, as are the cemnomts I’m really looking forward to reading the next part. That element of surprise and weirdness (weird in a good way) in all of the prequels, but specifically and overwhelmingly in TPM, is something that I love, too. Despite the ultimate wish of the hateboys to have him hand Star Wars over to somebody else (or their despicable pining for his demise), nobody else can bring that quality to Star Wars like GL can. Sure, somebody else may be able to give you lightsaber battles, armored troops, bounty hunters flying around in jet-packs though it’s worth noting that all those things came from GL himself but nobody else is going to give you Watto, Boss Nass, Dexter Jettster, Jira, EV-9D9, Jar Jar, Neimoidians with Flash Gordon view-screens, or countless others and that’s not even taking into account the unexpected course of the actual *story*.|
|i really apperciate you writing this, there aren’t a lot of intelligent assessments of the phantom menace to be found online, + you’re right, the wannabe film critics (i can’t think of anything i’d wannabe’ less) are out in force now due to the re-release + red letter media’s irrational foaming hate revival’.but i’ve also noticed that as the children of ’99 enter their teens + early twenties the field is beginning to level out a little, + i’m seeing more + more even-handed appraisals of the movies.i wrote pretty much the same thing a few days ago regarding the intro to anh, in the interest of negating people’s complaints about there being too much politics’ in tpm. besides the fact that its structure is very similar to empire, including its action-to-drama ratio.i’ve also been busy reminding people that on the whole, the prequel trilogy was reviewed better than the originals at the time of release. it mightn’t look good if you only bothered to do as much research as checking the fresh-o-meter, but consider also that most reviewers’ these days are fanboys w/nothing more than a laptop + an opinion.an appeal to public opinion means nothing to me anyway, because i hate the public. + that’s the first + best argument a lot of the time; everyone’ else hates it, you must just be stupid. but besides the fact that tpm is one of top-grossing movies of all time anyway, besides the fact that it was reviewed favourably before the backlash gained momentum, the masses are the worst judge of art anyway. why should anyone ever even bring it up? because they aren’t capable of critical thinking + are afraid not to go along w/the crowd.no-one liked empire strikes back when it was released either, + now look.geez, *people* are the reason lucas found it so hard to get the movies made in the first place.i also wrote something similar about the reason i loved the movie as much as any previous sw movie + others didn’t may be because i grew up largely ignorant of eu, + wasn’t even aware a prequel trilogy was even in the cards.even as a kid i just thought episode iv’ was an artistic choice, so while sw was my favourite set of movies, they were over, + there was no reason to formulate preconceptions of what more movies would be like.i love how you illustrated the difference between the messages of the trilogies + the correlation between it, the respective times of release, + people’s reaction. very, very insightful.that was what i loved about phantom menace most at the time of release, was the political machinations. anticipating how this leads to the fall of the republic. finding real-world analogues, + you make a salient point; it was a remarkably precient movie in that respect (tho unfortunately this speaks more to our inability to learn from history than any pre-cognizance on lucas’ part).here’s what i wrote the other day, to illustrate where i was at in this process; my sister + i were talking last night about how the jedi are basically the *baddies* in the prequel trilogy, + wondering if that’s not part of the reason people say they don’t love the characters as much as in the ot.instead of a scrappy + small band of rebels fighting to overthrow the corrupt + indifferent empire, it’s a small scrappy group of sith trying to overthrow a corrupt + indifferent republic. it’s very hard to know who to root for, but this is what i love. it’s nowhere near as black + white as the ot, it’s much more subtle, shaded, ambiguous + morally unsatisfying. i’m not saying the ot was simplistic, only that by that time, it was pretty clear-cut what had to be done (kill the empire. it’s evil). whereas in the pt, the goodies’ are running around clueless for three movies unwittingly doing all the baddies dirty work *for* him.this is especially why characters like qui-gon + padme9 + bail organa are among my favourites, because they are the voices of reason in the pt (+ to a certain extent yoda, but he’s pretty bad too). this leads me to your comments about the origin’ story. i love origins too, + the prequels have added so very much to my appreciation of established characters like obi-wan, as well as fleshing out characters that were previously only mentioned, like bail organa who is now one of my favourite characters too.yeah, you know a lot of what’s gonna happen in an origin story, but if that mattered to people, superboy wouldn’t have been the most popular comic of the 50s. of course superboy is going to survive each adventure, but it’s about seeing how he survives, what he learns from it, + how it contributes to the man he’ll become.besides, i mean, did anyone ever believe there was the chance luke skywalker was going to get eaten by the wampa? course not, even tho his future wasn’t known at the time. kids don’t think about things like story convention. they don’t care. this is a much more pure receipt of stories.one thing i disagree with is that the prequels *were* all that different from the ot. they were certainly different, but not like a totally different movie, not the way some people act like they’ve abandoned that star wars feeling’.if they were too very different, i probably wouldn’t have instantly loved them as much. the way i describe it is that the trilogies are constructed to be like mirrors to each other. the image seen in a mirror is not the same, it is an exact + symmetrical *opposites* of each other. one is just the reflected other, as you yourself alluded to, by mentioning the inversion of the protagonists’.anyway, looking forward to reading more.|
|I knew that something had haepenpd similar before here in the US but I didn’t know the details. Thanks so much for the link.As for CPR training, there is something similar in our emergency training at work where we single out people and give them a simple command for them to perform. For the flight attendants, it is something like, You and you, go down and hold the slide! You, go down and lead people away! Otherwise you have those who can’t move out of terror and those who will leave a shoe print in your back as they walk over you.|
|Jaco Strauss||feedback_at_strauss.za.com||New functionality|
|I’ve now added the functionality to rate this page, please do so.|
|kofi essien||kofi_at_fidelity_bank.com.gh||individual rights|
|But what about the rights of the citizens????|
|Don't you guys have better things to do than write huge articles about STAR WARS|
|Lawrence||law1_ca_at_hotmail.com||The Article Does Make Sense|
|I have to admit that when you look at it the Empire doesn't really change the life of law abiding citizens. I mean really, if you are smuggling or doing other illegal activities then yeah the Empire will try and really crack down hard.
I'm also worried about how the rebel forces will govern the galaxy. First off, do they intend to return the government to the old republic's galactic senate? If so, then prepare for the return of a huge, bloated, inefficient and overly corrupt government, because that's what happened to the old Republic, which became really awful during its last decade or so of life. In a sense the Rebels have no idea on how to properly run a galaxy and honestly I would NOT want to live in a galaxy run by the rebel alliance, because for one thing crime would explode. With no authority and order smuggling, slavery, and other underground syndicates would flourish due to the rebel's inability to govern effectively. Take away all of the "evil" images of the Emperor and Darth Vader and what do you have? You have a strong, powerful, effective if sometimes aggressive government, which seeks to maintain order and peace throughout the galaxy. As far as I can tell, the average person who pays taxes and lives a relatively ordinary life will not be affected by the Empire in most situations.
In closing, I would like to say that you might think the Galactic Empire is bad and sometimes harsh; however, a government run by the Rebel leaders would be chaotic, inefficient, weak (when it comes to stamping out resistance against them and crime), and in general far, more dangerous for the average person. In this case, the Empire is actually the lesser of two "evils", if you want to call it that. :)|
|Brian||random_rogue_at_hotmail.com||Empire is good|
|I couldn't agree more with this artical. To call the Empire evil is to Call the Old Republic Evil, which in turn your call the Rebels evil since thats what they're fighting for. The only true loyal people to the republic was the Seprtists when they split and did their own thing. Well not Loyal to the Republic, but the its ideas. The only change between the Empire and the old republic was A> A shift of power from the Light side to the Dark side. This does not effect average joe citizen one bit. His life continues as normal just as it did when any chancelor took over from the Senate. B> Local leaders were given more control of their districts. This works a lot smoothers as local leaders deal their own issues. -- I would also like to point out that it took 20 years (From Ep3 to Ep4) for the Emperor to disolve the senate. The Rebels should have fought in the senate to have things changed rather then on the battle field. It would have saved Aldaronn from destruction. So much for Padme's belief that things should be handled in the Senate.|
|Tautalos||Anonymous||Yes and No.|
|The Empire is wrong, not for advocating «evil» (anyway, NO doctrine or regime ever standed for «evil», the worst tyrants always claim to be «good» and «liberators»), but for being totalitarian and enemy of freedom.
It's not a pawn of the devil, obviously; but it's downfall is more good than bad.
As for the Jedi, yes, they are pretty arrogant and dogmatic, quite irritating, similar to the most impositive religious missionaries of some religions.
|join the dark side,i love it ,a good article,you anti's are all brainwashed|
|mess with me Robert (Lucifer)||davidsonprince_at_yahoo.com||what are your plans|
|for once forget about earth and tell me what are your plans you can email me i'm not dumb enough to fall for this if they've made movies about jesus i think i know you exist that is all |
|WOA WOA WOA!!!!!Back up BACK UP!! Ok, I have quite a few comments about this. Yes, I do agree with the expanded-universe and all, but OMGosh! Ok, this is A LOAD A' CROCK!!!! Well, since no. 3 hasn't come out, this is probably how it goes. The Separatists are squashed, and Palpatine is shocked at the victory and turns the Republic into an Empire, turning the clone troopers into stormtroopers and uses them to eradicate all of the Jedi. And then probably the cloning station on Kamino is destroyed by the Rebels, so the Emperor, a big turd, gets Imperial Academies to recruit troops. I do agree with the jedi being a Royalist Swiss Guard but they ain't arrogant. The Republic does supposedly want to squish the separatists into the manure, because they don't want "this Republic that has stood for so long be split in two". Well, the EMPIRE IS EVIL!! Basically, they want to blast anyone in their way to get what they want! It's like fighting to the death over a piece of gum! The Dark Side is bad, not just because it is dark, but also because it encourages people to do bad things, like Temptation does! And, um, the destruction of Alderann actually proves that piece-of-gum war. It proves that vthey will do anything to have thier way, including mudering billions of people! Ok, about the comments. First, Chad, this is nothing like the Nazis. You can't just compare Stalin to Yoda just because you hate the Rebels. Jacob is just as guilty. Ok, Benny thank you for informing us of whatever was on Alderann and all. Annnnnnnnnnnnnnnnd Sean. ok, Leia is a lier, but she lied to the Empire. And Luke isn't a fake. He is fighting for a cause that many other people believe in, but I am not going to get into that right now. About the lightning and bla bla, I don't think that you actually would have used Mind Trick, cause a jedi seeks peace, not mass destruction. Fil, uh, hmm... i'll go to Rog. Ok, the Jedi aren't stone-headed zen workers. Every Star Wars fan knows that. About Kerry, uh, if you don't like the Rebels, just say so. BillY, well, i think Drew fits the comparison to the Empire and BushCo. Carrie, well, he is not so right. Drew, APPLAUSE SIGN GOES UP! YEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA! I toast to Drew, thanks. |
|Chad||frederickbarbarossa_at_msn.com||Darth Vader is Adolf Hitler|
|The parallels become ever to clear and I agree with Johnathon, wholeheartedly. I would add that Adolf Hitler trying to Unite all Europe into an Aryan Reich(Kingdom) gave His whole life to this effort, in the end to be defeated by Mongolian like clones from Red Russia, bungling Americans, who knew nothing of the situation, and a British Empire that was too greedy. Now note, that in the world's eyes the Third Reich lost WWII, but in actuallity it did not. To sacrifice oneself for the Good, is to gain a Millenial Kingdom soon to come. The highest thing a man can do is to lay down their life for their people's future. So Stormtroopers will be returning from outer space, Hitler will be coming back. While Yoda is Koba(Joseph Stalin), Stalin also had a top man called Yagoda, as for Palpatine, he is a Franklin Delano Roosevelt, and Obi-wan Kenobi is a Winston Churchill. As for the Empire, it goes to show you that the world of heathens and chaos, fought against Hitler's Reich of Order based on Race and Blood Purity. Whereas Luke, and Han fight with Yoda, Ewoks, Chewbacca, and a thousand other weird looking creatures, which represent the different primitive races of earth. As for the Sand People, they killed Luke's uncle and aunt, not Vader. These same Sand people, had killed Anikan's mother, on that same planet. Alas, Obi-Wan wants Luke to think Anikan did it. Obi-Wan has sided with Yoda(Stalin-Communism). Vader could have blasted many of their planets and bases right out of the galaxy but did not. He could have killed Leiah, and Luke many times but did not. He tells Luke that he was right about him, for the last time Luke spoke to Leiah, he told her that his father was good. The Dark force that Vader speaks of is really good. To hate evil is good, yet it is the Dark part of the Force. There is no turn the other cheek attitude here. If people are evil and will not submit to Rule by Christ, then they shall be killed. This is the attitude. So in WWII Waffen SS in the Totenkopf division wore a Death's Head on their Helmets for they were to execute judgment on the evil. This is the Dark side of the force, yet it is Good. Now their is a Dark side which is evil also. There is also a group of people that say peace peace, but in reality want destruction. This is Yoda. Lucas, writes the script from the minds of our generation how it is viewed. In WWI, Adolf Hitler was a Trench runner, the best there was. And was on the front 4 years. He was seen as the Christ, which He is, and millions of His people joined Him. Yet the heathens, and deceived America, and Britian joined together to destroy Europe. If you look at a Map, most of Europe joined with Hitler. As for Palpatine F.D.R., the movie is made to look like Vader is with F.D.R., or the same as F.D.R., yet Lucas shows this is not the case, for Vader destroys F.D.R. and his Melting Pot Kingdom. Whereas the Mongolian Clones clearly represent the Communist Reds of Stalin with Yoda commanding. Winston Churchill was jealous of Adolf Hitler for the love His people gave Him. As for the colors Red, Black, and White of Darth Vaders Empire, they are the colors of Deutschland in WWI and WWII. It is quite clear that when Hitler is killed by His own Aryan peoples Hate, as Vader said only there hate can kill me, or make me go away. For Luke was really hating the good and not the evil. As America has now become ever corrupt, and filled with materialism, and loves evil and hates good. Only their love for what is good can bring Christ back. Indeed when thousands of Aryans pray for Hitler return He will return. While Stalin killed over 70 million Aryans. Hitler killed the people who were killing the Aryans. May the Force be with you. The Dark side of the Force, which seeks good, by executing judgment, is the Force that will bring Light. |
|Benny||mastakenobi_at_hotmail.co.uk||The facts of Alderaan|
|The Rebels claim that Alderaan was a peaceful and defenceless world, but in reality it was quite different.
The Alderaan Royal Engineers (ARE) were part of a secret rearmament program that was initiated on Alderaan (by the Royal House of Alderaan), but they ceased operations since the Empire stopped them by destroying the planet.
Viceroy and First Chairman Bail Organa gave up his seat in the Imperial Senate and returned to Alderaan. From there he worked hard to convince his people to renounce their pacifist ways. And before Alderaan could fully prepare its military might and officially join the Rebellion the planet was destroyed.
Viceroy and First Chairman Bail Organa, working with Mon Mothma diverted weapons and funds into the hands of organizations opposed to the Empire (the early form of the Rebels) after the Ghorman Incident. More so, Bail Organa supplied highly classified military data to Rebel leaders, which allowed them to conduct surprise attacks against Imperial shipping and troops.
Bail Organa made Alderaan a centre for dissent and resistance. A quotation that came from the Rebels' own propaganda pamphlet "A Call to Reason".
Alderaan was conducting major sums of secret Rebel activities.
Sections of the Alderaanian palace were constructed of mono-molecular plates which allowed so much of the palace itself to survive the destruction of Alderaan. Underground portions of the palace were hardened to protect the Royal Family from attack, and those portions of the palace also survived.
The Council of Elders were going to give the Rebel Alliance the Alderaanian War Frigate Another Chance, which was filled with weapons.
Alderaan secretly maintained one Alderaanian War Frigate (Another Chance) and three Thranta-class War Cruisers (Courage, Valiant and Fidelity) [which were slave rigged to the Another Chance].
Alderaan supplied large numbers of troops to the Rebels, including the training, uniforms, weapons and equipment for those troops. The uniform of the troops are Alderaanian. Note that the Rebel Trooper wears the Alderaanian uniform.|
|I agree with Jonathan actually, Leia is a liar Luke is a fake, the Empire WILL do alot better than the old republics and besides, lets face it the Dark side is alot more powerful than the light side. If i was stuck in the middle of a battle with blaster loving rebels I would rather Force Lightning through the battlefield than use Force Mind Trick and convince them to buy a stack of Barbie Dolls. And compare Bush to Vader? HELL NO! Vader has a saber and Bush does not. Simple as that|
|Fil||philip.rechnitzer_at_hurlburt.af.mil||Princess or Emporers|
|Seems like there wasn't a choice for freedom regardless. Wasn't "brother kissing" Leia a PRINCESS? At what point does anyone assume that a Rebellion win means freedom for the galaxy?
In the end, were I this galaxy, I'd be pretty sick and tired of the Skywalker line...its just like the Kennedys, and they have wrecked everything and continue to do so (hello Teddy)....|
|Finally! Someone other than me sees the Jedi for what they are, Stone headed zen wonkers that bring about their own destruction by being completely unmalleble. Oh yeah, I think the Rebels were led by Kerry. "Anyone but Palpatine!"|
|Sorry Drew but trying to equate Bush with the Empire doesn't wash.Bush is Elected and rule by the Senate(Congress) is about as effectual as the UN.Lucas' parallels to government today and in this world is frightening as we see the flaws in both.Until we come up with a better way(even the Nazis thought they were right,ditto the Communists) we have to survive in this one.Someone will always be hurt by any govrnment because as Lincoln said ,"You can't be all things to all people."|
|You are so right. While I might be emotionally tempted to sympathize with the anarchic goals of the elitists, I have to admit that their lack of planning is disastrously short-sighted.|
|Drewfirstname.lastname@example.org||You can have the Empire|
|I'm sorry, this is a load of crock. The destruction of Alderaan isn't as brutal as it appears? The Dark Side isn't bad, it just wants order?
I'm not going to go through this step by step. I will note that there are several paralells to be seen between the "order loving" empire and the current BushCo administration.